The legal aspect of short-term rentals with Airbnb
The problematics of legal frame of “short-term rentals” and the possibilities of legal defense against their providers
The Czech Republic, especially its capital Prague, has seen in recent years a surge in the number of real estate offered for short-term rental by their owners or tenants (1). Amongst these short-term rentals includes the Airbnb service, which serves as an online marketplace where home or flat owners rent their property for a short period of time to guests in return for a processing fee, be the guests local or foreign, whereas the rented property cannot be categorized as a hotel or an official accommodation facility.
Due to the recent emergence of Airbnb, it is not yet subject to direct legislation in the Czech Republic, therefore its operation can generate many problems.
Under what definition and legal regulation does a short-term rental fall under?
Generally it is possible to include the Airbnb service in the category of “short-term rental”. The definition of a short-term rental can be found exclusively in the text of the Act No. 235/2004 Coll., on Value Added Tax, in connection with the provision on exceptions from tax exemption of lease of real estates. According to the Act on Value Added Tax, a short-term rental of a real estate is a rental of premise which includes building, buildings or units, alternatively together with indoor moveable facilities or supply of gas, electricity, heating, cooling or water that lasts continuously for up to 48 hours at maximum (2). A long-term rental has to last for at least 48 hours – in that case the performance is exempt from value added tax without an entitlement to tax deduction.
Short-term rentals can however be put into other legal categories, under different acts and ordinances determining for example; fees for the accommodation capacity or assigning the providers with specific duties, while failure to perform them entails sanctions. The following text briefly summarizes them, as these are issues that Airbnb, its providers and everyone who is affected by the service, will have to deal with now or in the near future.
Duties of an Airbnb provider
Prior to discussing this, it is necessary to address the question of whether a short-term rental can be considered as performance of a trade within the Act No. 455/1991 Coll., on licensed trade (the Trade Licensing Act) (3). Standard lease of houses, flats and non-residential premises do not fall within a licensed trade, however accommodation services (for instance hotels or guest houses) do. Including providing accommodation in flats or family houses (Government Decree No. 278/2008 Coll. furthermore states that “where accommodation is provided in residential buildings, houses or family recreation centres with a capacity of up to 10 beds (including extra beds), breakfast is provided for the guests“ (4), as stipulated by the Government Decree No. 278/2008 Coll., on the content of individual trades (5). Airbnb would thus logically fall within the category of accommodation services.
Accommodation services are subject to fiscal and other statutory duties (6). A provider is obliged to announce performance of a trade to the Trade License Office and to pay an administrative fee. Failure to do so constitutes an infraction and the offender faces a fine up to CZK 500,000 (7). In addition to income tax, a provider is also obliged to pay a fee for the accommodation capacity to the municipality in the amount up to CZK 6 for each bed provided by day (8) and at the same time to keep a registration book for these purposes (9), and to levy radio and television broadcasting fees, provided that he uses the receivers within the business activity (10).
According to the information provided by Ochranný svaz autorský (OSA, the protection union of authors) the Airbnb providers should - if they dispose of reproductive technical tools in their rented spaces - levy radio and television broadcasting fees, or more precisely apply to the OSA for a license to use copyrighted works.
Another matter concerned with the performance duties of a provider is contained within Act No. 326/1999 Coll., on the residence of foreign nationals in the territory of the Czech Republic (11). For the purpose of the respective Act, a provider of accommodation is anyone who provides accommodation for pecuniary consideration or provides accommodation to more than five foreign nationals, if they are not considered as next of kin (12). Every provider is obliged to report to the foreign police department that a foreign national (more precisely a citizen of a country outside the European Union) has been provided with accommodation within three working days after the provision of accommodation (13) and to maintain a guest register (14). A provider who does not comply with the duties imposed by the law commits an administrative offence and faces a fine up to CZK 50,000 or alternatively up to CZK 5,000 in the case that the offence is heard in an administrative hearing on a citation (15).
Can another legal classification be considered?
On the other hand, it can be argued that Airbnb falls under the category of lease. As such it cannot be included within performance of trade with regards to section 3 subsection 3 letter ah) of the Trade Licensing Act, which explicitly excludes lease of houses, flats and non-residential premises from the category of trades (16). Simultaneously, duties concerning tax levies and suchlike would be different.
Furthermore, there may arise a situation when a tenant runs the Airbnb service in a leased house, flat or even a room without consent from the lessor (lessor´s consent is necessary when a tenant does not permanently live in the place - 17) or in spite of his explicit prohibition as stipulated in the lease agreement. This constitutes a gross violation of tenant´s duties (18) and as a consequence a lessor can withdraw from the contract.
Disturbing neighbors, pollution of shared premises or decrease in value of real estate
Providing short-term rentals, especially in buildings consisting of individual flats, may not be convenient for neighbors. For example, if an individual owns a property in an affluent district in Prague, he most likely does not wish that anyone can access the building and in addition to this he may be disturbed by the loud antics of his short-term neighbors. Further problems can also be created when guests do not behave appropriately in such shared premises or cause damage to the property.
Decrease in security of the building, noise, pollution and damages of shared premises or shared facilities - broken elevator, locks, entrance door, even flooding or thefts, violation of fire regulations, failure to report accommodation of foreign nationals to the foreign police etc.: are all issues that can arise whilst running the Airbnb service. The most burdensome impact however, is a decrease in value of real estate where the provision of short-term rentals take place.
How to redistribute collective costs and fees?
On the contrary, the Unit Owners Association (Společenství vlastníků jednotek – SVJ) often has to address, how to allocate service costs per person, if an owner of a residential unit runs the Airbnb service.
A new civil code, the Act No. 89/2012 Coll., stipulates that approval of the type of services and the amount of advance payments for these services, as well as the method of billing each unit for these services lies within the scope of competence of assembly of the SVJ (19). The aforementioned is affirmed by the Act No. 67/2013 Coll., regulating certain matters related to provision of performance connected to use of flats and non-residential areas in a building of flats, which stipulates that the method of billing of service costs is determined by the SVJ (20).
If however the SVJ does not stipulate any rule, then service costs are allocated in a different manner. In the case of water supplies and drainage of sewage water, the costs are counted proportionately according to measured figures on subsidiary water meters or according to determinant numbers of annual water needs. Whereas costs for other services - operation of an elevator, lighting, cleaning of shared premises etc. - are distributed according to the number of persons decisive for billing (21), while decisive persons are a tenant or an owner of a flat and all persons who are assumed to live in the unit for a period of time longer than two months during relevant accounting period (22).
Guests using Airbnb mostly do not spend more than two months in the unit, which could cause problems with allocating fees per person in a house of flats (23). Nevertheless, as statute grants the SVJ discretionary powers on cost distribution, as mentioned above, in practice the fees can be collected for a precise number of people who live in a flat or a house or who are accommodated there.
Possibilities of legal defence
If the provider of an Airbnb accommodation cannot regulate the behavior of his guests, there are adequate legal steps which can be taken by those affected by the nuisance.
It ultimately always depends on the type of ownership an Airbnb provider holds his house or flat unit in. If there is private ownership, an owner can dispose of his flat according to his consideration, provided that he adheres to maintaining hygienic norms and does not disturb others of course. A cooperative accommodation however constitutes a certain obstacle for possibilities of short-term rentals – cooperative association can determine in their statutes that consent to a sublease, or short-term rental will not be given (24).
As for owners of units, the Civil Code regulates that the person who has acquired the right of ownership to a unit has to announce it - including his address and number of persons who will use the flat as a household - to the other owners of units through the person responsible for administering the building no later than one month from the date he learned or could have learned that he became an owner (25). Furthermore, it is the owner´s duty to notify without undue delay the person responsible for administering the building about a change in the number of persons who use the flat as a household and who live there for a total period of at least three months in one calendar year (26).
Guests accommodated via Airbnb however cannot be considered persons who use the flat as a household and in most cases they do not spend enough time there to fulfill the period of time of at least three months, thus the owner´s notification duty does not apply to them according to the above mentioned provision. In this case therefore, the options as to how to react to short-term neighbors and providers of their accommodation are limited to dealing with violations of hygienic norms, disturbance of peace and quiet at night or damaging shared premises or alternatively settlement of disputes concerning allocating service costs as mentioned above, violations of statutes of the SVJ, interference with the right of ownership et cetera. As it results from the law, a unit owner is obliged to follow the rules for building administration and for use of shared premises as well as to ensure compliance with these rules by all persons who the unit owner enabled access to the building or the flat (27).
In the view of the fact that running the Airbnb service can entail many factual and legal issues, it is more than necessary to guarantee a clear legal regulation for these types of short-term rentals as soon as possible. Until that happens, Airbnb will continue to remain in an uncertain legal vacuum.
About rutland ježek:
The rutland ježek law firm in Prague focuses mainly on business law, real estate law, litigation, finance and banking law; the firm is ready to provide adequate comprehensive consulting thus offering an alternative for clients of international law firms. The international dimension of the provided services is guaranteed by its track record and cooperation with leading law firms in most European countries, the USA and other jurisdictions. Czech lawyers of the rutland ježek team have long experience in providing legal consulting to transnational corporations, large Czech companies as well as medium size firms and individuals, acquired in leading international law and tax firms. More on www.rutlandjezek.com.
We provide legal consultations to the SVJ representatives or neighbors who are disturbed by the Airbnb service run in the building as well as to unit owners whose SVJ does not act in the case of disputes amongst the unit owners. We are able to provide consultancy and take legal action on any other issue which can arise in connection with Airbnb.
1 - There were 10,000 active lease offers in the Czech Republic at the end of first quarter of 2016 (ČERNÝ, Aleš. Manažer AirBnB: Praha je u nás čtvrtým nejžádanějším městem v Evropě. In: idnes.cz [online]. 2016 [cit. 2016-09-07]. Available at: http://ekonomika.idnes.cz/rozhovor-s-andrew-verbitsky-z-airbnb-dsy-/ekonomika.aspx?c=A160318_154653_ekonomika_rny)
2 - Section 56a subsection 2 of the Act No. 235/2004 Coll., on Value Added Tax
3 - Act No. 455/1991 Coll., on licensed trade (the Trade Licensing Act)
4 - Point 55, Annex No. 4 to the Government Decree No. 278/2008 Coll., on the content of individual trades
5 - Point 55, Annex No. 4 to the Government Decree No. 278/2008 Coll., on the content of individual trades
6 - FIALA, Vojtěch. Právní povaha krátkodobého ubytování. In: epravo.cz [online]. 2016 [cit. 2016-09-07]. Available at: http://www.epravo.cz/top/clanky/pravni-povaha-kratkodobeho-ubytovani-102612.html
7 - Section 61 subsection 4 letter c) of the Act No. 455/1991 Coll., on licensed trade (the Trade Licensing Act)
8 - Section 7 subsection 4 of the Act of ČNR No. 565/1990 Coll., on local fees
9 - Section 7 subsection 3 of the Act of ČNR No. 565/1990 Coll., on local fees
10 - Section 5 subsection 3 of the Act No. 348/2005 Coll., on radio and television broadcasting fees
11 - Act No. 326/1999 Coll., on the residence of foreign nationals in the territory of the Czech Republic
12 - Section 99 subsection 1 of the Act No. 326/1999 Coll., on the residence of foreign nationals in the territory of the Czech Republic
13 - Section 102 subsection 1 of the Act No. 326/1999 Coll., on the residence of foreign nationals in the territory of the Czech Republic
14 - Section 100 letter f) of the Act No.326/1999 Coll., on the residence of foreign nationals in the territory of the Czech Republic
15 - Section 157 subsections 7 and 8 of the Act No. 326/1999 Coll., on the residence of foreign nationals in the territory of the Czech Republic
16 - Section 3 subsection 3 letter ah) of the Act No. 455/1991 Coll., on licensed trade (the Trade Licensing Act)
17 - Section 2275 subsection 1 of the Act No. 89/2012, the Civil Code
18 - Section 2276 of the Act No. 89/2012, the Civil Code
19 - Section 1208 letter e) of the Act No. 89/2012 Coll., the Civil Code
20 - Section 5 subsection 1 of the Act No. 67/2013 Coll., regulating certain matters related to provision of performance connected to use of flats and non-residential areas in a building of flats
21 - Section 5 subsection 2 letters a) and d) of the Act No. 67/2013 Coll., regulating certain matters related to provision of performance connected to use of flats and non-residential areas in a building of flats
22 - Section 2 letter g) of the Act No. 67/2013 Coll., regulating certain matters related to provision of performance connected to use of flats and non-residential areas in a building of flats
23 - Airbnb a poplatky za služby. In: Dostupný advokát [online]. 2016 [cit. 2016-09-08]. Available at: https://dostupnyadvokat.cz/blog/airbnb-poplatky-za-sluzby
24 - Airbnb a poplatky za služby. In: Dostupný advokát [online]. 2016 [cit. 2016-09-08]. Available at: https://dostupnyadvokat.cz/blog/airbnb-poplatky-za-sluzby
25 - Section 1177 subsection 1 of the Act No. 89/2012 Coll., the Civil Code
26 - Section 1177 subsection 2 of the Act No. 89/2012 Coll., the Civil Code
27 - Section 1176 subsection 2 of the Act No. 89/2012 Coll., the Civil Code
Exchange places may face new regulations by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV (Foto: fotolia)
The Finance Ministry is currently handling a proposal for better oversight
Employment sets new records by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV (Foto: fotolia)
Women reach highest share of workforce, and employment hits a new high
Daimler may build Czech warehouse by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV
The carmaker is looking for a site for part for the CEE region
US Ambassador Schapiro ends his term by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV (Foto: Anglo American University Prague)
Incoming president Trump has asked all political appointees to step down on inauguration day
Filing US Taxes Abroad by Emily Prucha - Prague.TV (Foto: fotolia)
Expat taxes for Americans living & working in the Czech Republic
Exchange of Kč 50 notes ends soon by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV
More than 11 million of the invalid banknotes are still out there
Congress Center Prague to get overhaul by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV (Foto: Congress Center Prague FB)
The unpopular communist-era building will be revamped but not destroyed
Prague's economy growing again by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV
Statistics show the entire country has improved
Did you join the CDK Global Bored? Bus for a Career with More Colour? by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV
The Business Service Center once again brought colour to the streets on Prague!
Prague passes Kč 62 billion budget by Raymond Johnston - Prague.TV (Foto: Prague.eu)
Transportation will get the biggest single portion of spending
... the real luxury is actually waiting for you on your...
Looking for a memorable experience in Prague?
Take a guided tour to Sapa, Prague’s “Little Vietnam”
Have fun. Help. Volunteer overseas - Let us organize your...
We do more for travellers
CST has been open in Prague since June 2016
Zebra Technologies EMEA
IT advisory, development and outsourcing